glass cliff
noun; business, politics and social psychology

- A situation in which someone receives a senior position under conditions that make failure particularly likely

- The promotion of a disadvantaged or minority-group member into a precarious position of authority

- A professional advance offered to a woman or minority-group member during a crisis or period of poor performance

Cambridge Dictionary, Collins English Dictionary, Dictionary.com

—
PHRASE ORIGIN

“Glass cliff” entered academic English in 2005 through research by British social psychologists Michelle K. Ryan and S. Alexander Haslam. Their work was prompted by a 2003 Times article claiming that appointing women to company boards harmed share prices.

Ryan and Haslam re-examined FTSE 100 companies and found a different sequence: poor share-price performance tended to precede the appointment of female board members. Their paper described such appointments as positions on a glass cliff.

The metaphor deliberately extends glass ceiling, the invisible barrier preventing women and minorities from reaching senior positions. Breaking that ceiling may reveal another invisible danger: the available foothold is precarious. A ceiling obstructs the climb; a cliff makes the achievement itself hazardous.

—
WHO OWNS THE FAILURE?

A football club loses six matches, sacks its manager, then wins. The directors look decisive; the new coach looks inspired.

But the sequence can fool us. A run of unusually bad results is often followed by less extreme ones simply because chance fluctuates. Statisticians call this regression to the mean. The low point prompts the dismissal, so the natural recovery arrives just in time to resemble the result of bold leadership.

A study covering 8,392 Belgian football matches found that teams improved within four games of dismissing their coach. Further analysis, however, indicated that the improvement came from regression to the mean rather than the replacement. Comparable teams that retained their managers often recovered too.

This matters beyond football. A leader appointed during a crisis inherits depleted funds, poor morale, missed targets and decisions made years earlier. If performance keeps falling, observers see the newcomer at the wheel and assume causation. If it recovers, a statistical bounce may be mistaken for heroic intervention.

The fair question isn’t simply, “Did results improve?” It is, “What would probably have happened without the appointment?” That invisible alternative is difficult to estimate and impossible to observe directly.

A glass cliff is a job judged from a starting line that everyone soon forgets.

Helga & Paul Smith

—
SYNONYMS

crisis appointment, GLASS CLIFF, poisoned chalice, setup for failure

—

SMUGGLE OWAD into a conversation today, say something like:

“The promotion looked historic, but the collapsing division made it a GLASS CLIFF.”

____________________

PLEASE SUPPORT US

On evenings and weekends, I research and write your daily OWAD newsletter together with Helga (my lovely wife and business partner) and our insightful daughter Jennifer. It remains FREE, AD-FREE, and ALIVE thanks to voluntary donations from appreciative readers.

If you aren't already, please consider supporting us — even a small donation, equivalent to just 1-cup-of-coffee a month, would help us in covering expenses for mailing, site-hosting, maintenance, and service.

Just head over to DonorBox:

https://donorbox.org/owad-q4-2023-5
   or
Bank transfer:

Paul Smith

IBAN: DE75 7316 0000 0002 5477 40
(Important: please state as 'Verwendungszweck': "OWAD donation" and the email address used to subscribe to OWAD)

Thanks so much,
Paul Smith